
- Plain Jane and the Mermaid
- by Vera Brosgol
- First Second
- Publication Date: May 7, 2024
- ISBN-13: 9781250314857
Plain Jane. She doesn’t have looks, according to her late parents and the townsfolk, and soon she won’t even have a home – girls aren’t allowed to inherit property, and her odious cousin wants her out. Her only chance to save her home is marriage, but her prospects are nonexistent. Jane approaches her crush, the handsome fisherman’s son, Peter, and proposes a marriage of convenience: she’ll keep her home, and he can quit fishing. If only that pesky mermaid didn’t steal Peter away!
Plain Jane and the Mermaid subverts fairy tales with a heroine who doesn’t rely on others to save her as she sets forth on a quest to rescue her prince, save her home, and discover her hidden strength. There are tropes such as the smart, but plain, girl facing a beautiful, but evil, adversary, and beauty comes from within, yet Brosgol makes them seem new and adventurous. A modern classic in the making.
Readers who enjoy Brosgol’s Anya’s Ghost and Be Prepared will love her latest. Similar titles with appeal are The Prince and the Dressmaker by Jen Wang and Nimona by ND Stevenson, which also subvert fairy tales and have art styles which make them stand out; or The Girl From the Sea by Molly Knox Ostertag, if mermaids are also part of the appeal.
–Melanie C. Duncan
Other Nominated Titles


