Quick Picks for Reluctant Readers (#QP2026) Feature Review: One of the Boys by Victoria Zeller




  • Levine Querido



Former star football kicker Grace is struggling to settle into her senior year of high school after coming out as trans when her former teammates offer her an opportunity to rejoin the team. Grace navigates tough choices between her new life and new friends and all the things she misses about her former life – including and especially football – while confronting anti-trans behavior from classmates and the world at large as news of her decision to play gets out.

This is an exceptionally timely and important tale that is grounded in relatability and a whole lot of heart. Grace is a complicated character who often makes the “wrong” choice, which makes her that much more likeable and appealing to a wide range of teen readers. The author uses sometimes sarcastic, sometimes frank language that feels authentic to the teen experience. Grace is surrounded by a compelling group of secondary characters, including a wide array of queer teens exploring their own paths. The book’s suburban setting – at times more progressive than you’d expect and at times painfully transphobic – might appeal to queer teens outside of more diverse, urban environments (where many stories of queer teens take place). But Grace’s – and the author Victoria Zeller’s – love for football is the real standout here; Grace’s dedication to the sport and her teammates is infectious, and the author does a superb job of capturing its essence for fans but also making it appealing, exciting and clear for non-sports fans as well. 

A wide range of teens will like this book – sports fans, queer teens, and fans of realistic stories about senior year. Give to fans of recent sports books like Byron Graves’ Rez Ball or shows like Friday Night Lights and All American. This title would also appeal to fans of books about the trans experience like Meredith Russo’s If I Was Your Girl and Alex Gino’s Melissa.

–Maryanne O.